There exist small subcultures and small communities that do not engage in slut shaming among their members. Create a docudrama around how they operate.
It cannot be a documentary because often the subcultures are stable only because their sexual behavior remains secretive: the larger culture does not know. Once the secret is revealed, the community collapses, often catastrophically.
Polyamorous subculture is the one exception to secrecy, though it is often somewhat kept under wraps, and many members of the larger culture do not want to associate with them.
Such subcultures often form around athletes and pop stars: groupies. I would be surprised if teenagers are not forming such subcultures around their teenage athletic peers (very surprised given the sexual proclivities of teenagers and their tendency to form tight knit social groups). Thus, I speculate this was what was happening in Steubenville, and it helps rationally explain why it seems to happen often (Maryville, MO).
Assuming such subcommunities remain stable for generations and decades, how do they do so in the face of inevitable instances of sexual assault? I strongly suspect that the lack of slut shaming avoids the majority of the harm of the assault, so much so that what little harm remains is tolerable compared to the rest of the benefits of the social community.
If true, the tremendous irony of the destruction (by incarceration and by publicity) of the Steubenville social group is it was the destruction of a social group that did not do slut shaming, that was doing it right, that should be celebrated as opposed to derided. We can see just how powerfully the larger culture's status quo of slut shaming is heavy handedly enforced on those of who deviate from it, by zealous -- and well-meaning! -- individuals participating in a catastrophic culture clash.
Assuming we wish to permit such subcultures to exist because they are the seeds of good, what policy changes would facilitate it? The obvious one, legalizing sexual assault and rape, would probably cause more harm than good. Furthermore, I suspect it wouldn't work: you can't legislate social change.
No comments :
Post a Comment